Background/Objectives: Recurrent meningiomas remain difficult to manage due to the absence of effective systemic therapies and comparatively high treatment failure rates, particularly in high-grade tumors. Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) offers a minimally-invasive and precise option, particularly for tumors in surgically complex locations. However, the risks associated with re-irradiation, and recent changes in the WHO classification of CNS tumors highlight the need for more personalized and strategic treatment approaches. This systematic review evaluates the safety, efficacy, and clinical considerations for use of SRS for recurrent meningiomas. Methods: In accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, a systematic literature search was conducted using the PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases for studies reporting outcomes of SRS in recurrent, pathologically confirmed intracranial meningiomas. Studies were excluded if they were commentaries, reviews, case reports with fewer than three cases, or had inaccessible full text. The quality and risk of bias of the included studies were assessed using the modified Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. Data on patient and tumor characteristics, SRS treatment parameters, clinical outcomes, adverse effects, and statistical analysis results were extracted. Results: Sixteen studies were included. For WHO Grade I tumors, 3- to 5-year progression-free survival (PFS) ranged from 85% to 100%. Grade II meningiomas demonstrated more variable outcomes, with 3-year PFS ranging from 23% to 100%. Grade III tumors had consistently poorer outcomes, with reported 1-year and 2-year PFS rates as low as 0% and 46%, respectively. SRS performed after surgery alone was associated with superior outcomes, with local control rates of 79% to 100% and 5-year PFS ranging from 40.4% to 91%. In contrast, tumors previously treated with radiotherapy, with or without surgery, showed substantially poorer outcomes, with 3- to 5-year PFS ranging from 26% to 41% and local control rates as low as 31%. Among patients with prior radiotherapy, outcomes were particularly poor in Grade II and III recurrent tumors. Toxicity rates ranged from 3.7% to 37%, and were generally higher for patients with prior radiation. Predictors of worse PFS included prior radiation, older age, and Grade III histology. Conclusions: SRS may represent a reasonable salvage option for carefully selected patients with recurrent meningioma, particularly following surgery alone. Outcomes were notably worse in high-grade recurrent meningiomas following prior radiotherapy, emphasizing the prognostic significance of both histological grade and treatment history. Notably, the lack of molecular and genetic data in most existing studies represents a key limitation in the current literature. Future prospective studies incorporating molecular profiling may improve risk stratification and support more personalized treatment strategies.
Mizutani et al. (Sat,) studied this question.