A Defense of the Doyle Rule

Key Points

• The Doyle rule continues to play a significant role in forestry practices despite ongoing criticism.
• Scientists and practitioners have condemned the Doyle rule, yet it remains important for many foresters.
• One forester's justification of the Doyle rule highlights its relevance in modern forest management.
• The persistence of the Doyle rule reflects the challenges faced in adapting forest practices within American forestry.