The macroevolution of sexual size dimorphism in birds

Abstract There is considerable variation of sexual size dimorphism (SSD) in body mass among animal groups, yet the drivers of interspecific variation in SSD are still poorly understood. Possible mechanisms have been suggested, including sexual selection, selection for fecundity in females, niche divergence between sexes, and allometry, yet their relative importance is still poorly understood. Here, we tested predictions of these four hypotheses in different avian groups using a large-scale dataset on SSD of body mass for 4761 species. Specifically, we estimated the probability of transition between male- and female-biased SSD, tested for differences in evolutionary rates of body mass evolution for males and females, and assessed the potential ecological and spatial correlates of SSD. Our results were consistent with the sexual selection, fecundity, and niche divergence hypotheses, but their support varied considerably among avian orders. In addition, we found little evidence that the direction of SSD affected the evolution of male or female body mass, and no relationship was detected between SSD and environmental predictors (i.e. temperature and precipitation seasonality, productivity, species richness, and absolute latitude). These results suggest that avian evolution of SSD is likely to be multifactorial, with sexual selection, fecundity, and niche divergence playing important roles in different avian orders.