Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
The nitrogen (N) isotopic composition of diatom frustule-bound organic matter (15NDB) from sedimentary archives has been used as a promising proxy indicator to reconstruct nitrate utilization in the high-latitude oceans on different timescales. The advantage of this proxy over conventional N isotopic approaches, such as measuring 15N values of the bulk sediment, is that 15NDB is thought to be protected from diagenetic alteration and bacterial degradation. Despite the fact that the 15NDB proxy has been applied in palaeoceanographic research for two decades, little is known about the propagation of the 15N signature of assimilated nitrate into biomass 15N and subsequently into 15NDB, and to what extent N-isotope fractionation during frustule-bound N synthesis varies among species and with environmental conditions. Only few 15NDB data exist for living diatoms in natural environments or laboratory cultures, and implications for paleo-environmental reconstructions appear controversial between existing studies. Here, we present novel constraints on the relationship between 15N values of nitrate, diatom bulk biomass, and diatom frustule-bound N across samples from different natural environments and from controlled mono-specific diatom cultures. While previous ground-truthing work has focussed on marine diatom species both in culture and in the ocean, we extend our study to freshwater species and lacustrine environments. We find that, in mono-specific diatom cultures,15NDBvalues are generally relatively close to biomass15N values, irrespective of the variable 15N-fractionation imparted by nitrate assimilation. Similarly, analysis of diatom samples from natural environments revealed little offset between15NDBand bulk biomass15N values in samples that are near mono-specific. By contrast, in more mixed-species samples,15NDBvalues can be shifted in both directions relative to biomass15N values, possibly as a result of i) species-specific N isotope fractionation during frustule-bound N synthesis, and/or ii) non-uniform contribution of N to the total biomass and diatom-bound N pools between different species.
Studer et al. (Fri,) studied this question.