Silitex conductive textile electrodes achieved the highest ECG signal quality among tested materials with median correlation R of 0.9919, SNR of 17.2518 dB, and PRD of 13.7334%, with no statistically significant differences compared to other textile materials.
Do conductive textile electrodes provide comparable ECG signal quality to standard Ag/AgCl electrodes in human volunteers?
Five different conductive textile materials demonstrated suitable ECG signal quality compared to standard Ag/AgCl electrodes, supporting their potential use in wearable monitoring devices.
p-value: p=NS (no statistically significant difference at α=0.05)
The implementation of textile electrodes offers the possibility of improving comfort and reducing the risk of allergic reactions of the measured subject, while also opening the door to non-medical devices for everyday life. The main objective of the experiment is to test and compare five conductive fabrics manufactured by Shieldex in terms of the quality of the measured electrocardiography (ECG) signals. For this experiment, 3 electrodes of each conductive material were made and tested on a sample of 20 volunteers. The electrodes were attached by an elastic band at the locations of selected standardized ECG leads, and Ag/AgCl electrodes were used as reference. Correlation coefficient (R), signal-to-noice ratio (SNR) and percentage root-mean-square deviation (PRD) applied to representative cardiac periods were used to evaluate the quality of the acquired data. Differences in the results of the evaluation parameters between the different positions were noted, and when the distribution of positions was neglected, it was discovered that the best results were obtained with Shieldex Silitex material and, on the contrary, the worst results were recorded with Shieldex Technik-tex P130 + B material. It was also found that the results were not significant between the materials and after visual inspection it can be concluded that all materials are suitable for ECG measurements.
Lajdolf et al. (Fri,) conducted a other in Adults aged 18-72 years with variable somatotype undergoing ECG monitoring with conductive textile electrodes (n=20). Conductive textile ECG electrodes from Shieldex (types: Balingen, Bonn, P130 + B, P180 + B, Silitex) vs. Conventional Ag/AgCl adhesive ECG electrodes was evaluated on Quality of ECG signal measured by textile electrodes compared to reference Ag/AgCl electrodes using correlation coefficient (R), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and percentage root-mean-square deviation (PRD) (p=NS (no statistically significant difference at α=0.05)). Silitex conductive textile electrodes achieved the highest ECG signal quality among tested materials with median correlation R of 0.9919, SNR of 17.2518 dB, and PRD of 13.7334%, with no statistically significant differences compared to other textile materials.