Biomaterials have emerged as promising therapeutic alternatives in clinical conditions in which bone regenerative capacity is limited, whether due to trauma or pathological bone loss. Among these, collagen-based materials, hydroxyapatite (HA), and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) have been extensively investigated, while elastin has more recently gained attention as a substrate for tissue regeneration. This study aimed to evaluate bone repair in femoral defects in rats treated with elastin- and collagen-based membranes subjected to controlled alkaline hydrolysis under different processing conditions, used alone or combined with HA or recombinant human BMP-2 (1.1 µg per defect). A total of 77 rats underwent surgical creation of a non-critical unicortical femoral defect (3 mm diameter) and were allocated into seven groups: defect without graft (control); elastin membrane; elastin membrane + HA; elastin membrane + BMP-2; porcine intestinal serosa–derived collagen membrane; collagen membrane + HA; and collagen membrane + BMP-2. Histological analyses confirmed the biocompatibility of all membranes, with no evidence of inflammatory response. Elastin membranes, when used alone or combined with HA, did not significantly enhance bone repair compared with the control group; however, their association with BMP-2 improved osteogenesis. In contrast, collagen membranes, whether used alone or combined with HA or BMP-2, demonstrated superior bone formation and integration. In conclusion, the evaluated biomaterials exhibited osteogenic potential in non-critical femoral defects, and BMP-2 significantly enhanced outcomes, particularly when combined with collagen-based scaffolds.
Machado et al. (Wed,) studied this question.