Studies of insulin resistance in patients with clinical and subclinical hypothyroidism

OBJECTIVE: Although clinical hyperthyroidism (HR) is associated with insulin resistance, the information on insulin action in subclinical hyperthyroidism (SHR) is limited. DESIGN AND METHODS: To investigate this, we assessed the sensitivity of glucose metabolism to insulin in vivo (by an oral glucose tolerance test) and in vitro (by measuring insulin-stimulated rates of glucose transport in isolated monocytes) in 12 euthyroid subjects (EU), 16 patients with HR, and 10 patients with SHR. RESULTS: HR and SHR patients displayed higher postprandial glucose levels (area under the curve, AUC(0)(-)(300) 32,190±1067 and 31,497±716,mg/dl min respectively) versus EU (27,119±1156 mg/dl min, P<0.05). HR but not SHR patients displayed higher postprandial insulin levels (AUC(0)(-)(300) 11,020±985 and 9565±904 mU/l min respectively) compared with EU subjects (AUC(0)(-)(300) 7588±743 mU/l min, P<0.05). Homeostasis model assessment index was increased in HR and SHR patients (2.81±0.3 and 2.43±0.38 respectively) compared with EU subjects (1.27±0.16, P<0.05), while Matsuda and Belfiore indices were decreased in HR (4.21±0.41 and 0.77±0.05 respectively, P<0.001) and SHR patients (4.47±0.33 and 0.85±0.05 respectively, P<0.05 versus EU (7.76±0.87 and 1 respectively). At 100 μU/ml insulin, i) GLUT3 levels on the monocyte plasma membrane were increased in HR (468.8±7 mean fluorescence intensity (MFI)) and SHR patients (522.2±25 MFI) compared with EU subjects (407±18 MFI, P<0.01 and P<0.05 respectively), ii) glucose transport rates in monocytes (increases from baseline) were decreased in HR patients (37.8±5%) versus EU subjects (61.26±10%, P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Insulin-stimulated glucose transport in isolated monocytes of patients with HR was decreased compared with EU subjects. Insulin resistance was comparable in patients with both HR and SHR.