Traditional electromagnetic theory draws a one-sided conclusion that charged particles undergoing curved orbital motion will continuously lose energy and radiate electromagnetic waves outward. This view serves as the core prerequisite for special quantum hypotheses such as probability clouds and superposition states. Based on the fundamental mechanical work formula W=Fs·cosθ, this paper clarifies that the necessary condition for energy loss is the generation of unidirectional effective radial displacement along the direction of the acting force. Electron orbits are bound by Coulomb force, and celestial revolution is constrained by universal gravitation. These two types of forces are always perpendicular to the tangential motion direction of particles. For circular orbits, the total work done by forces is zero. Within a full cycle of elliptical orbits, the positive and negative work generated by gravitation and Coulomb force cancel each other out completely, leaving no net energy loss. Coulomb force and universal gravitation only change the direction of motion without producing sustained unidirectional radial displacement, so they cannot consume the kinetic energy of the system. Macroscopic celestial revolution and microscopic electron orbits follow the same set of mechanical and energy conservation rules, which proves that the inference "charged particles must radiate and lose energy during curved motion" is a fundamental logical error. The zero-energy-consumption characteristic of circular motion is the underlying foundation for the constant stability of the universe, yet the academic community denies this key objective law, and all ad-hoc hypotheses including probability clouds and superposition states established on this wrong deduction lose their basis for existence.
Jiaqing Yan (Thu,) studied this question.