Fish passage through turbines is one of the main environmental impacts of hydropower. Turbine type is a key factor influencing fish survival, and widespread Kaplan turbines are generally considered less dangerous than other turbine types. Nevertheless, while large Kaplan turbines have been extensively studied, there is limited empirical evidence about the biological impact of small, high-speed Kaplan turbines on fish survival. In this study, we conducted controlled in situ fish experiments at a small and low-head hydropower plant (1 MW; head 8 m) using balloon tags and pressure sensors to quantify real mortality in two horizontal Kaplan turbines operating at full capacity: one small turbine (1.2 m Ø, 500 rpm, and 5 m3/s) and one larger unit (1.55 m Ø, 300 rpm, and 8 m3/s). Fish (95–190 mm) were released into the intake flow and monitored post-passage. Results showed higher mortality in the small turbine, with ~80% in 24 h, many exhibiting severe mechanical injuries such as complete sectioning of the head or spinal cord, with significantly higher mortality in larger fish. In contrast, the larger turbine showed a ~60% mortality rate and fewer traumatic injuries. Our findings highlight the underestimated impact of small, high-rpm Kaplan turbines on fish survival and underscore the need for adaptive turbine operation or structural modifications to minimize ecological damage during critical migration periods.
Sanz-Ronda et al. (Wed,) studied this question.