Accurate Digital Terrain Models (DTMs) are essential for managing forest drainage networks as a crucial element of water management, yet dense canopies and complex micro-topography challenge Airborne Laser Scanning (ALS) precision. This study evaluates the vertical accuracy of an ALS-derived DTM specifically within forest drainage ditches, utilizing 706 GNSS and total station measurements for validation. The results indicate a positive elevation bias, with a mean elevation error of 0.415 m and an RMSE of 0.464 m, 54.7% higher than the 0.3 m declared in the DTM technical report. Forest height, acting as a proxy for forest structural density and canopy closure, was significantly associated with a reduction in ground reflection density and an increase in the distance to the nearest ground reflection (p < 0.05). Mixed-effects ANOVA confirmed that there are significantly more ground reflections in low vegetation (0–1 m). Crucially, multiple regression analysis revealed that forest height was not the primary driver of elevation error; instead, ditch geometry was the most significant predictor. Narrower ditches exhibited substantially higher errors than wider ones, regardless of the canopy height. Furthermore, while ground reflection density decreased in mature stands, this reduction did not significantly diminish DTM vertical accuracy, suggesting that some of the LiDAR reflections of low vegetation could be misclassified as ground reflections, decreasing accuracy. These findings suggest that while ALS is effective for general forest topography and mapping drainage infrastructure, its application may require corrections for ditch dimensions rather than vegetation height alone to mitigate systematic overestimation of ditch bed elevations.
Duchan et al. (Tue,) studied this question.