Achieving natural esthetics has become essential for successful dental restorations and supports the use of modern non-metal materials. However, complexity in esthetic features of natural teeth, determined by both inherent color factors and hierarchical and gradient microstructures, makes recording, determination, and reproduction difficult. This often leads to misunderstanding during manufacturing and dissatisfaction with the final outcome, even when using advanced digital tools. The aim of this study was to investigate a new, easy-to-handle digital tool for determining the color of restorative materials. An industrial-level handheld color identifier, the NCS Colourpin SE, together with the corresponding NCS color system, was tested on three materials: dental resin nanocomposite, self-glazed zirconia (SGZ), and Decore zirconia pellets. The repeatability and impacts of geometrical contributions such as surface roughness and thickness on different colors were measured. The Colourpin SE offered promising repeatability. Decore zirconia showed more than 90% repeatability for most of the colors, independent of thickness. The NCS scanner showed slightly better repeatability than earlier in clinical trials with an intraoral scanner. The shades A3.5 and A3 had lower repeatability, varying from 50 to 90%. It identified effects of material thickness and surface roughness, where the thicker samples were identified with higher blackness levels, and surface roughness seemed to be coupled with a lower blackness level in color identification codes. Small but consistent differences between materials were detected, suggesting that material and manufacturing methods affect the final shade. The NCS Colourpin SE shows potential to be developed into an affordable and easy-to-handle scanner for the identification of a patient’s tooth color, enabling synchronization with digital workflows and improving the match between restoration and the patient’s natural teeth. Nevertheless, further research and development in customized applications for color identification in esthetic dentistry is still required through multidisciplinary collaboration.
Basso et al. (Sat,) studied this question.