The growing urgency of resource-efficient construction in water-stressed and rapidly urbanizing regions necessitates integrated decision support frameworks that move beyond isolated sustainability metrics. This study operationalizes the water-energy nexus within building design evaluation by developing a structured hybrid multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) framework tailored to the Indian construction context. Unlike conventional sustainability assessments that treat water and energy independently, the proposed approach integrates life cycle-based water consumption, operational and embodied energy demand, environmental impacts, economic feasibility, and project constraints within a unified analytical hierarchy. A Delphi-validated criterion structure comprising five main criteria and twenty sub-criteria is weighted using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), and ranked using the VIKOR compromise solution method. To strengthen methodological robustness, ranking outcomes are validated across three independent MCDM logics including TOPSIS, PROMETHEE, and COPRAS. The framework evaluates four representative building strategies aligned with Indian regulatory and certification systems (NBC, ECBC, IGBC/GRIHA, and net-zero water-energy design). Using expert-informed weights derived from a Delphi–AHP involving a panel of experienced practitioners, the VIKOR compromise ranking consistently identifies the net-zero alternative as the most favorable option within the evaluated framework. The results are therefore interpreted as an expert-informed assessment demonstrating the applicability of the proposed decision support methodology rather than as statistically generalizable priorities for the entire Indian construction sector. The study contributes by (i) embedding nexus-based resource interdependence into building-level MCDM modeling, (ii) enhancing transparency through explicit benefit-cost classification and decision matrix disclosure, and (iii) demonstrating ranking stability across multiple validation techniques. The proposed framework provides a transferable methodological approach that can be adapted to different regional contexts through locally derived expert inputs.
Davis et al. (Sat,) studied this question.