Coupled fates of Earth’s mantle and core: Early sluggish-lid tectonics and a long-lived geodynamo

Conventional Earth evolution models are unable to simultaneously reproduce two fundamental observations: the mantle’s secular temperature record and a long-lived geodynamo before inner core nucleation. Today, plate tectonics efficiently cools the mantle, but if assumed to operate throughout Earth’s history, past mantle temperature and plate motion become unrealistically high. Through coupled core-mantle modeling that self-consistently predicts multiple mantle convection regimes, we show that over most of the Precambrian, Earth likely operated in a distinct “sluggish-lid” tectonic mode, characterized by partial decoupling between the lithosphere and mantle. This dominant early regime is due to a hotter Earth and the presence of the asthenosphere. This mode regulates the core-mantle boundary heat flow, which powers the geodynamo before inner core nucleation. Both sluggish-lid tectonics and a long-lived dynamo demonstrate the inextricably connected paths of the core-mantle system. Moreover, our simulations simultaneously satisfy diverse geological observations and are consistent with emerging interpretations of such records.