The Nigerian oil industry remains the central pillar of the country’s political economy, supplying critical fiscal revenue and foreign exchange while paradoxically failing to deliver commensurate broad-based development. This paper interrogates the prebendal system—a political culture of rent-distribution, patronage, and clientelism—and how it undermines meritocratic principles in the oil sector, thereby constraining economic advancement and positive development despite large oil earnings. Using meritocracy theory as a conceptual framework and employing qualitative descriptive methods with secondary quantitative data like NNPC financials, production/export statistics, and macroeconomic indicators), the paper shows that prebendal dynamics creates corruption, elite capture, oil theft, patronage in appointments and contracts. Similarly, it distort resource allocation, reduce incentives for competent management, and concentrate benefits within narrow networks. The paper concludes with policy and governance reforms aimed at restoring meritocratic recruitment and decision-making, strengthening transparency and accountability, and redesigning institutional incentives to translate oil wealth into sustainable development. Keywords: Nigerian oil industry, Prebendal system, Rent-distribution, Meritocracy, Elite capture, Oil theft, Economic development, Governance reforms, Transparency, Accountability
Onya et al. (Wed,) studied this question.