Previous studies have shown that ammonia emissions can be continuously reduced through the application of a urease inhibitor (UI) in cattle and pig farming. However, there is no information on whether the use of these inhibitors also has an effect on other emissions, and whether it leads to an increase or decrease in these emissions. In this study, carbon dioxide, ammonia, methane, nitrous oxide and odour emissions were measured in three mechanically ventilated, fully slatted pig fattening houses in Germany during 2019–2020. The UI was applied daily to compartments, and effects on emission values were comparatively analysed using four different calculation approaches: linear mixed model, direct case-control, case-control in time and a novel ratio-difference approach. As expected, a significant reduction in ammonia emissions of 22–24 % was observed across all four calculation approaches and all three farms, confirming the effectiveness of the UI; no decisive effects on carbon dioxide, methane or odour emissions were found. Effects on nitrous oxide emissions could not be reliably analysed due to low concentrations which were below the Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) quantification limit. It is recommended to calculate the reduction effect using a combined approach so that over- and underestimation of the effect can be avoided. Two approaches are available for this purpose: the ratio-difference and linear mixed model. The ratio-difference approach has a simplicity of calculation and the ability to achieve results very similar to those of the linear mixed model.
Schulte et al. (Mon,) studied this question.