Does a magnetic earring PPG sensor accurately measure heart rate compared to an FDA-approved ECG device during daily activities?
A novel magnetic earring PPG sensor demonstrates high correlation with FDA-approved ECG for heart rate monitoring during standing, walking, and running.
This paper addresses the design considerations and critical evaluation of a novel embodiment for wearable photoplethysmography (PPG) comprising a magnetic earring sensor and wireless earpiece. The miniaturized sensor can be worn comfortably on the earlobe and contains an embedded accelerometer to provide motion reference for adaptive noise cancellation. The compact wireless earpiece provides analog signal conditioning and acts as a data-forwarding device via a radio frequency transceiver. Using Bland-Altman and correlation analysis, we evaluated the performance of the proposed system against an FDA-approved ECG measurement device during daily activities. The mean +/- standard deviation (SD) of the differences between heart rate measurements from the proposed device and ECG (expressed as percentage of the average between the two techniques) along with the 95% limits of agreement (LOA = +/-1.96 SD) was 0.62% +/- 4.51% (LOA = -8.23% and 9.46%), -0.49% +/- 8.65% (-17.39% and 16.42%), and -0.32% +/- 10.63% (-21.15% and 20.52%) during standing, walking, and running, respectively. Linear regression indicated a high correlation between the two measurements across the three evaluated conditions (r = 0.97, 0.82, and 0.76, respectively with p < 0.001). The new earring PPG system provides a platform for comfortable, robust, unobtrusive, and discreet monitoring of cardiovascular function.
Poh et al. (2010) studied this question.