Water saturation is a key factor influencing the mechanical behavior and stability of tunnel rock masses in water-bearing strata. However, current research based on physical model tests has yet to systematically reveal its intrinsic relationship with rock failure modes. To address this gap, this study systematically investigated the effects of water saturation levels (0%, 33%, 58%, and 100%) on the failure mechanisms of four typical tunnel cross-section models: wall-arch, horseshoe, circular, and square. The results indicate the following: (1) Water saturation exerts a significant deteriorating effect on the mechanical properties of tunnel models. As saturation increases, peak stresses generally decrease across all models, but the extent of deterioration varies markedly by tunnel shape: at low saturation (≤58%), peak stress follows the order Wall-Arch > Horseshoe > Circular > Square; at high saturation (>58%), this relationship reverses to Circular > Square > Wall-Arch > Horseshoe. (2) The failure mechanism is significantly controlled by saturation, exhibiting distinct transition characteristics: At low saturation, capillary effects dominate, with matrix suction enhancing material strength, resulting in brittle failure with crack concentration. At high saturation, pore water pressure effects prevail, reducing effective stress and leading to plastic failure dominated by distributed shear slip. Notably, square tunnels consistently exhibit pronounced flexural failure characteristics across all saturation levels. (3) Energy evolution analysis indicates the following: as saturation increases, the total energy U of specimens decreases, the dissipation rate of dissipated energy Ud accelerates, the energy inflection point advances, and failure precursors manifest earlier. The energy dissipation factor n of high-saturation specimens decreases more significantly with increasing strain, confirming that moisture accelerates energy dissipation and promotes premature material instability. (4) Significant differences exist in the response characteristics to moisture effects among tunnel types: Square tunnels consistently exhibit pronounced flexural failure; Circular tunnels demonstrate optimal stress distribution properties under high water content conditions; Wall-arch and horseshoe-shaped tunnels are most sensitive to saturation changes, with their failure modes transitioning from tensile-dominated to shear failure as water content increases. This study reveals the coupled mechanism between water saturation and tunnel cross-sectional shape in influencing rock mass stability.
Wang et al. (Sun,) studied this question.