Tropical forests differ widely in floristic composition, stand structure, standing volume, and carbon storage, yet comparative evidence across contrasting tropical forest types remains limited. This study examined whether variation in standing volume and carbon stocks among contrasting tropical forests was more closely associated with structural attributes or with diversity-related patterns. Two tropical wet forests in Colombia and one tropical semi-deciduous forest in Mexico were evaluated using 40 circular plots of 500 m2 established within a 100 ha reference area in each forest, where all trees with DBH > 10 cm were measured. Floristic composition, ecological dominance, diversity, dendrometric attributes, standing volume, biomass, and carbon stocks were estimated using a common analytical framework. The two wet forests showed higher effective diversity, broader taxonomic dominance, greater basal area, mean height, standing volume, biomass, and carbon stocks than the tropical semi-deciduous forest. In contrast, the semi-deciduous forest showed stronger dominance concentrated in fewer taxa, especially Euphorbiaceae, a pattern that may reflect the ecological suitability of this family under more seasonal and water-limited conditions. At the family level, standing volume, biomass, and carbon were distributed more evenly among dominant families in the wet forests, whereas they were more concentrated in fewer lineages in the semi-deciduous forest. Basal area showed the strongest association with standing volume, total biomass, and total carbon, followed by mean height and mean DBH. Overall, the results indicate that, under the conditions evaluated, structural organization was more closely associated with standing volume and carbon storage than diversity alone, while diversity acted as a complementary correlate.
Hernández-Alvarez et al. (Sun,) studied this question.