While it is well established that bacterial genomes encode multiple and diverse antiphage systems, the reasons for their co-occurrence and their heterogeneous distribution remain debated. This review examines why bacteria accumulate antiphage systems and how this influences phage–bacteria interactions, particularly in the context of phage therapy. Two main hypotheses may explain this phenomenon: (i) the pan-immunity hypothesis, which suggests that defence system accumulation provides protection against phage predation at the community level, and (ii) mobile genetic element (MGE) competition, where defence systems primarily protect intra-bacterial MGEs against other ones rather than the bacterial host itself. The ecological context also influences the distribution of antiphage systems, with defencee accumulation shaping phage–bacteria interactions in diverse communities but playing a lesser role at the species level, potentially explaining why multiple defences do not strongly limit phage host range in therapeutic settings. Finally, we address the challenges in understanding the drivers shaping the distribution of defence systems across bacterial genomes (expressions, costs, etc.) and their implications for elucidating the ecological role of defence systems and optimizing phage therapy strategies. This article is part of the discussion meeting issue ‘The ecology and evolution of bacterial immune systems’.
Clabby et al. (Thu,) studied this question.