Abstract. Accurate and representative quantification of methane (CH4) emissions from individual oil and gas facilities is crucial to improve our knowledge of CH4 sources, improve the reliability of emissions reporting and help facilitate mitigation opportunities. Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) terminals primarily emit carbon dioxide (CO2) but are also potentially large CH4 sources in the gas supply chain. Here, in work supported by the United Nations Environment Program International Methane Emissions Observatory (UNEP's IMEO), we evaluate two airborne measurement approaches to quantify CH4 emissions from four LNG facilities. The first approach applies a downwind mass balance method to quantify emissions of both CH4 and CO2. Since operator-reported CO2 emissions are relatively well-established, we evaluate the method's performance by comparing to operator-reported CO2 values. Using this approach, we show that an individual facility CO2 mass balance quantification has a mean relative difference to operator reporting of ±20 %, with no significant mean bias across all estimates. The second approach uses measured CH4 : CO2 mole fraction ratios as an alternative method for estimating site-level CH4 emissions. Using this tracer correlation approach, we show that uncertainties in the ratio of CH4 : CO2 from a single day can be below ±10 % at the 95 % confidence level. Due to uncertainty in the CO2 emission rate, the resulting mean 2σ uncertainty on CH4 emissions is ±30 %. CH4 : CO2 ratios are found to vary with height, with larger variation at lower altitudes (<250 m). Representative sampling across both horizontal and vertical space is needed to enhance the accuracy of the tracer correlation approach for individual emission estimates. We find that when repeated over multiple days and different atmospheric conditions, ratio measurements below 250 m provide a median estimate that is within 5 % of the mass balance and multi-height ratio methods. Whilst the CO2 : CH4 emission ratios derived from measurements could be applied to estimate CH4 emissions over longer timeframes, the degree of representativeness will depend on the variability of the ratio over time. Our results indicate that the mass balance and the CO2-based tracer correlation approaches provide estimates of CH4 emissions from LNG facilities that are consistent with each other.
Lunt et al. (Thu,) studied this question.