DNAR: All or Nothing: Impact of Education Sessions Re-Audit in a Model 3 Hospital

Abstract Background Do Not Attempt Resuscitation (DNAR) orders are implemented to obviate inappropriate Cardio-Pulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) in patients with low chances of survival post-CPR. However, ambiguity regarding ceilings of care for patients with a DNAR order can arise. This re-audit aimed to review DNAR and ceilings of care documentation according to national HSE guidelines after education sessions, comparing results with the pre-education audit in a Model 3 Hospital. Methods A point-prevalence chart review of thirty-one adult medical inpatients with a DNAR order was conducted after two education sessions were held for Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors (NCHDs) and Consultants. Results Of all thirty-one charts, 35% documented DNAR status in the medical notes, with 32% documenting the reasoning for DNAR status, both of which were unchanged from the first audit cycle. There was an increase in documentation of patient discussion (61% versus 45%) and reasons if this was excluded (66% versus 41%). There was no change in documentation of patient relatives’ discussion (48%) but there was an increase in the reasons if this was excluded (25% versus 18%). There was an overall increase in ceilings of care documentation for ICU admission (three-fold increase), intubation (two-fold increase), inotropic support, and comfort measures, but rates of documentation were still less than 15%. This elucidates the efficacy of education sessions in improving DNAR documentation adherence. Recent studies have highlighted uncertainty among NCHDs regarding treatment escalation in acutely unwell patients in the absence of adequately filled DNAR orders and clear documentation of ceilings of care. Therefore, we posit the introduction of a Ceilings of Care document, akin to the United Kingdom’s Medical Advance Plan. Conclusion Accurate recording of DNAR status and ceilings of care is essential for quality care and treatment escalation. While simple education strategies have proven beneficial in enhancing compliance, additional efforts are needed to enhance ceilings of care documentation.