Rejoinder to Discussion of "Data Science at the Singularity"

Rejoinder to Discussion of "Data Science at the Singularity" 2 I am impressed by the number, diversity, and seriousness of the discussions.I sense general agreement about the data science reality that has been forming over the last decades, some of the larger forces driving it, and the resulting permanent changes to research computing and scientific publishing that will ensue.I also sense concerns and important reservations, maybe not so much about what my article says, but what it does not begin to acknowledge and discuss.Each discussant makes unique and valuable points about issues exposed by these rapid changes across a broad range of fields represented and topics discussed.I can only admire and celebrate these contributions.In this rejoinder I will refer to the original