Contrasting Effects of Nitrogen Deposition and Phosphorus Addition on Soil Organic Carbon in a Subtropical Forest: Physical Protection versus Chemical Stability

Soil organic carbon (SOC) not only contributes to maintain soil health, but is also important in regulating global climate change. How atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition and phosphorus (P) addition affects SOC dynamics remains unclear, especially in subtropical forests. The response of SOC in three layers to N deposition and P addition in this study is estimated by analyzing the soil aggregates and C chemical stability composition fertilized with N (100 kg N hm−2 a−1) and/or P (50 kg P hm−2 a−1) over 9 years in a Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) plantation. Treatments involving N deposition increased the SOC concentration, while P addition alone decreased the SOC concentration in soil layers above 10 cm. The addition of N significantly increased the mean diameter of topsoil aggregates, macroaggregates SOC concentration, and the contribution of N to total SOC. P addition decreased the relative abundances of aromatic and aliphatic functional groups while decreasing the chemical stability of SOC in the topsoil. A structural equation model indicated that N deposition promoted SOC concentration by mainly improving the physical protection of soil aggregates, while P addition reduced SOC sequestration by decreasing the chemical stability of SOC. Our research suggested that elevated N deposition might promote the soil C sink, while P fertilization would not be recommended under increased N deposition to protect soil C storage in subtropical forests.