Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Abstract While the position of alpine and arctic treelines can be predicted by climatic data, the underlying biological mechanisms are still unclear. In a recent paper in this journal (Körner C, Lenz A, Hoch G (2023) Chronic in situ tissue cooling does not reduce lignification at the Swiss treeline but enhances the risk of 'blue' frost rings. Alpine Botany https://doi.org/10.1007/s00035-023-00293-6 ) we presented results of an in situ stem-cooling experiment at a Swiss treeline site. The experiment provided answers to two entirely different questions, related to xylogenesis at treeline: (a) the absence of chronic effects of low temperature on lignification, and (b) a high time resolution insight into the rare occurrence of damages in young, still undifferentiated, and thus, non-lignified cells at the occasion of an exceptional early season frost event. In the last issue of Alpine Botany (August 7, 2023), our data had been re-interpreted by (Büntgen, Alpine Botany, 2023) by confusing (b) with (a). Cell death before secondary wall formation interrupts all metabolism, and thus, cannot exert a specific limitation of lignification. For the xylem to lignify, it requires a secondary cell wall in the first place. A frost damage in young tracheid cells is unsuitable for a dendrological treeline hypothesis based on a low-temperature threshold for lignification. Generally, the global pattern of treeline position is not associated with local freezing conditions.
Körner et al. (Mon,) studied this question.