Weld quality plays a critical role in ensuring the structural integrity and long-term performance of critical piping systems used across petrochemical, oil and gas, marine, and healthcare sectors. Although gas tungsten arc welding, shielded metal arc welding, and gas metal arc welding are widely applied in pipe fabrication, existing studies often examine these processes independently and provide limited insight into the comparative influence of process parameters on weld morphology, microstructure, and mechanical performance. This review consolidates findings from recent research to evaluate how welding current, arc voltage, heat input, travel speed, shielding gas composition, and joint preparation interact to affect weld bead geometry, heat-affected zone evolution, tensile properties, hardness, and overall weld integrity in piping systems. The primary objective of this review is to critically compare fusion welding process parameter optimization strategies and to identify unresolved challenges in achieving controlled weld root geometry for high-integrity piping applications. Recent industrial failure investigations, particularly in ethylene oxide service piping, further underscore the importance of weld root control. Several documented leak events were traced to excessive root protrusion and inadequate interpretation of non-destructive testing data, where elevated reinforcement disrupted internal flow and promoted turbulence-induced degradation. These recurring issues highlight a broader industry challenge and strengthen the need for improved root-height optimization in critical piping applications. A significant research gap is identified in the limited optimization of weld root reinforcement, particularly in gas tungsten arc welding processes, where most reported studies document root heights exceeding 3 mm. Achieving a root height below 2 mm, which is an important requirement for reducing flow-induced turbulence and meeting industry acceptance criteria, remains insufficiently addressed. This review highlights this gap and outlines future research opportunities involving advanced parameter optimization and improved process monitoring techniques. The synthesis presented here provides a comprehensive reference for enhancing weld quality in critical piping systems and establishes a pathway for next-generation welding strategies aimed at producing high-integrity weld joints compliant with the American Society of Mechanical Engineers B31.3 requirements.
Sohel et al. (Wed,) studied this question.