Abstract Mobile laser scanning (MLS) provides detailed point cloud reconstructions of forest environments and has potential for operational forest sample-plot surveying. This study evaluated the accuracy of MLS in deriving forest inventory attributes, including basal area (G), number of trees per hectare (TPH), total stem volume (V), basal area-weighted mean tree diameter (Dg) and height (Hg), and dominant height (Hdom). Experiments were conducted in managed boreal forests across 44 sample plots (370–2000 m2) using a Faro Orbis MLS system. Field measurements collected tree-by-tree (n = 4472) with callipers and clinometers during the previous summer served as reference data. We compared two alternative MLS data acquisition trajectories—closed loops (MLS-loop) and line transects (MLS-line)—and two processing workflows: (i) manually assisted tree detection followed by automatic tree measurements, and (ii) a fully automatic workflow. MLS-line provided similar or marginally improved accuracy compared with MLS-loop; however, the substantially shorter acquisition time of MLS-loop (19.0 min per plot on average) favoured its operational use over MLS-line (30.5 min). Clearer differences emerged between processing workflows. The fully automatic workflow identified and measured 74.1% of trees with diameter at breast height (DBH) 5 cm, whereas manual assistance in tree detection increased this proportion to 97.1%. DBH accuracy was similar for both workflows (root-mean-square-error RMSE ≈ 2.4 cm), but tree-height estimates were substantially less accurate under automatic processing (RMSE 6.2 m) than under the assisted workflow (RMSE 2.1 m). These differences propagated to plot-level estimates. Using the automatic workflow, RMSEs were 4.2 m2/ha for G, 610 trees/ha for TPH, 29.3 m3/ha for V, 2.3 cm for Dg, 1.6 m for Hg, and 1.9 m for Hdom. The assisted workflow notably improved accuracy, yielding RMSEs of 3.5 m2/ha for G, 54.0 trees/ha for TPH, 20.2 m3/ha for V, 1.2 cm for Dg, 1.3 m for Hg, and 1.2 m for Hdom when using closed-loop trajectories. Overall, the results emphasize the importance of assisted workflows for attributes sensitive to detection completeness, particularly TPH, while showing that kinematic MLS can efficiently capture forest structure for sample plot measurements.
Liikonen et al. (Mon,) studied this question.