Adaptive immunity is often viewed as a defining innovation of vertebrates, characterized by somatically diversified antigen-receptors and clonal lymphocyte lineages. Yet the evolutionary origins of such systems remain incompletely understood. In this review, we examine adaptive immunity from a comparative perspective across Metazoa, focusing on the design principles that link molecular diversification, immune cell differentiation, and proliferative dynamics. We first outline the two adaptive immune architectures found in vertebrates. Jawed vertebrates employ immunoglobulin-based and T cell receptor (TCR)-based recognition generated through RAG-mediated V(D)J recombination, whereas jawless vertebrates assemble variable lymphocyte receptors using cytidine-deaminase-dependent diversification of leucine-rich-repeat modules. Despite their distinct molecular entities, these systems converge on shared design principles, including somatic diversification, developmental restriction of genome editing, immune cell differentiation, and specialized microenvironments for immune education. To introduce evolutionarily more ancient systems, several diversification mechanisms of antigen-receptors in invertebrates will be subsequently surveyed. These systems generate substantial molecular diversity without canonical clonal selection, suggesting that immune recognition and diversification can be achieved through multiple evolutionary strategies. Particular attention is given to emerging insights into invertebrate immune cell diversification, where single-cell transcriptomics is revealing complex hematopoietic lineages and regulatory programs. These observations suggest that adaptive immunity did not emerge abruptly but rather represents one solution within a broader evolutionary landscape of immune diversification strategies. Understanding how diversification, proliferation, and cellular organization interact across animal lineages will help clarify the fundamental design constraints that shaped the evolution of vertebrate adaptive immune systems.
Taguchi et al. (Tue,) studied this question.