Cross-domain semantic classification of 3D point clouds remains challenging due to strong domain shifts between heterogeneous sensing modalities. Most existing classification frameworks are domain-specific, limiting their use in integrated land–water mapping applications. This study evaluates the transferability of classical geometric machine learning classifiers between terrestrial and underwater point cloud domains without target-domain retraining. Experiments were conducted using terrestrial data acquired with a Leica BLK360 terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) and underwater point clouds collected with a Blueview BV5000 mechanical scanning sonar (MSS). Two dimensionality-based frameworks, CANUPO–Support Vector Machine (SVM) and 3DMASC–Random Forest (RF), were implemented in CloudCompare and assessed under intra-domain and cross-domain configurations. Strong intra-domain performance was achieved, with terrestrial–terrestrial accuracies of 0.99 for CANUPO–SVM and 0.97 for 3DMASC. In underwater evaluation, CANUPO maintained high accuracy (0.97), whereas 3DMASC decreased to 0.86 due to increased variability in the submerged data. Under cross-domain transfer, CANUPO achieved 0.93 accuracy for terrestrial-to-underwater and 0.89 for underwater-to-terrestrial classification, while 3DMASC demonstrated stable generalisation with 0.95 accuracy in both directions. Overall, dimensionality-based geometric descriptors capture stable structural cues across sensing environments, providing an interpretable and efficient pathway for applications such as hydrographic surveying, coastal monitoring, and underwater search-and-rescue detection. Future work will extend validation to larger datasets and explore domain adaptation strategies to further reduce cross-modality domain shift.
Ntuli et al. (Sat,) studied this question.