Introducing Young Children to the Role of Assumptions in Proving

The notion of assumptions permeates school mathematics, but instruction tends to highlight this notion only in the advanced grades. In this article, I argue that it is important for even young children to develop a sense of the role of assumptions in proving, and I investigate what it might mean and look like for instruction to promote this goal. Toward this end, I study an episode from third grade that describes the first time that the students in the class were introduced in a deliberate and explicit way to the role of assumptions in proving. The central role of the mathematical task in the episode is identified, and features of mathematical tasks that can generate rich mathematical activity in the intersection of assumptions and proving are discussed. In addition, issues of the role of teachers in fostering productive interactions between students and mathematical tasks that have those features are considered.