Belonging to Orthodox Reformed churches was associated with a much higher epidemic poliovirus type 3 excretion rate (70.7 per 1,000 persons) compared to the crude population rate (2.5 per 1,000).
Cross-Sectional (n=3,182)
Yes
Does poliovirus circulate outside the group of people who reject vaccinations on religious grounds during an outbreak?
During the 1992-1993 outbreak in the Netherlands, poliovirus circulation was restricted to religious subpopulations rejecting vaccination, supporting the efficacy of herd immunity from inactivated polio vaccine.
Absolute Event Rate: 70.7% vs 2.5%
A population-based study on the circulation of epidemic poliovirus during 1992-1993 outbreak in the Netherlands was carried out in order to assess whether the virus circulated outside the group of people who reject vaccinations on religious grounds and outside the area where these groups form sociodemographically closely knit network. The prevalence of poliovirus excretion was estimated in a cross-sectional study with a random sample of 2,400 children aged 5-14 years and 3,000 adults age 40-64 years; the sample was drawn from the municipal population registers in four regions (three inside and one outside the risk area). Fecal samples of virus isolation and characterization were submitted by mail, and a questionnaire was completed with age, sex, type and level of education, vaccination history, and religious denomination. Both a completed questionnaire and a fecal sample were received from 3,182 persons (response, 58.9%). Wild poliovirus was isolated only from children within the risk group and in the area at risk. The crude excretion rate of the epidemic poliovirus type 3 per 1,000 persons was 2.5, but it amounted to 70.7 for those belonging to Orthodox Reformed churches. The prevalence of vaccine virus excretion per 1,000 persons was 10.2 for children and 5.2 for adults. It was concluded that, during the 1992-1993 outbreak, the risk of poliovirus was restricted to religious subpopulations rejecting vaccination. The lack of evidence of poliovirus circulation outside these groups at risk supports the hypothesis that herd immunity is sufficiently maintained in a population vaccinated with inactivated polio vaccine.
Spaendonck et al. (Wed,) conducted a cross-sectional in Poliomyelitis (n=3,182). Belonging to Orthodox Reformed churches (rejecting vaccination) vs. Overall population was evaluated on Excretion rate of epidemic poliovirus type 3 per 1,000 persons. Belonging to Orthodox Reformed churches was associated with a much higher epidemic poliovirus type 3 excretion rate (70.7 per 1,000 persons) compared to the crude population rate (2.5 per 1,000).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: