Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Evaluation compares student-created and faculty-created multiple-choice questions, suggesting training for better quality.
Problem-solving pedagogies are becoming more common for the instruction of science courses, and students frequently use online resources to facilitate their instruction. Learner-sourcing is one such pedagogical strategy whereby students design assessment items related to course content. This provides alternative learning opportunities, improved self-directed learning, and the development of course specific test banks. However, although studies have demonstrated how learner-sourcing can support student outcomes, there remains some reluctance from instructors to implement such approaches, citing the frequency of student misconceptions, lack of control of content, and poor-quality items. This study evaluates the quality of student-created multiple-choice (MC) items from a general chemistry 1 course as evaluated using the Item Writing Flaws Evaluation Instrument (IWFEI). These evaluations were then compared against faculty-created items that had been previously implemented on exams. The results from our data set demonstrate that student-created items contain comparable, if not fewer, item writing flaws than those created by faculty. We suggest that courses looking to use learner-sourcing pedagogies should invest in training students to identify item writing flaws, which could mitigate some of the concerns faculty have about the quality of student-created assessment items and provide opportunities for student-created items to support faculty generated exams.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jimenez et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: