Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Summary 1. The St. Johns River Water Management District removed over 5.4 million kg of gizzard shad ( Dorosoma cepedianum ) from Lake Apopka, FL during 1993–2005, as a means of reducing lake phosphorus and phytoplankton concentrations and improving water clarity. Other steps included reduction of external nutrient inputs and operation of a treatment wetland. We measured nutrient excretion by Lake Apopka gizzard shad to quantify the nutrient effect of this biomanipulation. 2. Both N and P excretion were significantly affected by fish body mass and temperature. Larger fish had lower mass‐specific rates of excretion than smaller fish. 3. High water temperature increased P excretion to a much greater extent than N, resulting in a low N : P of nutrient excretion in midsummer. The N : P of excretion was lower than has been observed in other systems, probably because of higher water temperature. 4. Removal of gizzard shad >200 g prevented the annual release of 45 800 kg N year −1 (3.46 kg N ha −1 year −1 ) and 7700 kg P year −1 (0.62 kg P ha −1 year −1 ) on average. The actual impact on the P cycle varied substantially from year to year (range 7900–78 800 kg N year −1 ; 1200–14 800 kg P year −1 ), primarily because of fluctuations in the catch. 5. On an annual basis, the P directly removed in fish tissues was similar to that removed by the treatment wetland. The P excretion prevented by the removal of fish was approximately 20% of the reduction in external P loading achieved during 1993–2005. 6. In the short term, most of the P demand of planktonic primary producers is met through recycling of P, which greatly exceeds external P loading. Depending on population biomass, phosphorus excretion by the resident gizzard shad population was similar in magnitude to the P release by diffusive flux from the sediments.
Schaus et al. (Mon,) studied this question.