Facilitation and Interference of Quercus Douglasii on Understory Productivity in Central California

Controversy over the effect of Quercus douglasii on the productivity of California grassland has been fueled by conflicting reports. In some studies, understory grassland productivity was < 25% of open grassland productivity, whereas in other studies understory productivity exceeded 200% of that of surrounding grassland. We examined light, temperature, soil nutrients, soil moisture, and fine tree root distributions under selected Q. douglasii trees (12 that appeared to have suppressive effects on understory productivity, and 12 that appeared to enhance understory productivity) in order to determine how variations in these factors were associated with the differences in understory grassland productivities. We found that grassland productivity is likely to be facilitated by nutrients inputs via litterfall and throughfall under all trees, but that trees with low understory grassland productivities has substantially higher amounts of fine roots in the upper 50 cm of soil and much lower predawn xylem pressure potentials than trees with high understory productivities and presumably deeper root systems. Root exclosures reduced the negative effects of these trees on the dominant understory grass species, and further experiments indicated that the negative effects of the tree roots may partially result from allelopathic oak root exudates. Thus, shallow fine tree roots may inhibit understory productivity, and variations in Q. douglasii root morphology may explain the intertree variations in facilitating/interfering effects on understory species.