Key evolutionary innovations and their ecological mechanisms

Explanations for taxonomic diversity in a particular clade often implicate evolutionary innovations, possessed by members of the clade, that are thought to have favoured diversification. We review such “key innovation”; hypotheses, the ecological mechanisms involved, and potential tests of such hypotheses. Key innovation hypotheses can be supported by evidence of ecological mechanism and by comparative tests. We argue that both are necessary for convincing support. In fact, few key innovation hypotheses are currently backed by either one. We group ecological mechanisms of diversification in three major classes. Diversification may be spurred by innovations that: I) allow invasion of new adaptive zones; II) increase fitness, allowing one clade to replace another; or III) increase the propensity for reproductive or ecological specialization. Key innovations in different classes are likely to produce different evolutionary patterns, and therefore may be supported by different kinds of ecological evidence.