Does 12 weeks of aerobic conditioning improve heart rate and RR interval variability in healthy, sedentary young adults compared to strength training?
Aerobic conditioning, but not strength training, improves cardiac autonomic regulation in healthy sedentary young men, though these cardioprotective effects reverse after 4 weeks of deconditioning.
OBJECTIVES: We tested the effect of aerobic exercise on autonomic regulation of the heart in healthy young adults. METHODS: Healthy, sedentary young adults (n = 149; age = 30.4 +/- 7.53 years) were randomized to receive 12 weeks of either aerobic conditioning or strength training. Primary outcomes were heart rate and RR interval variability (RRV) measured before and after training and after 4 weeks of sedentary deconditioning. RRV, a noninvasive index of cardiac autonomic regulation, reflects variability in the intervals between consecutive R waves of the electrocardiogram. RESULTS: Aerobic conditioning but not strength training led to a significant increase in aerobic capacity (3.11 mL/kg/min), a decrease in heart rate (-3.49 beats per minute), and an increase in high-frequency RRV (0.25 natural log msec2), each of which returned to pretraining levels after deconditioning. Significant 3-way interactions, however, revealed autonomic effects only in men. CONCLUSIONS: In sedentary, healthy young adults, aerobic conditioning but not strength training enhances autonomic control of the heart, but post hoc analyses suggested that gender plays a significant role in this exercise-related cardioprotection.
Sloan et al. (Fri,) studied this question.