UKCCSG's germ cell tumour (GCT) studies: improving outcome for children with malignant extracranial non-gonadal tumours—carboplatin, etoposide, and bleomycin are effective and less toxic than previous regimens

BACKGROUND: We report the efficacy and late effects of carboplatin, etoposide, and bleomycin (JEB) for extracranial non-gonadal tumours (GCII, 1989-95) compared with the 5 previous regimens (GCI, 1979-1988) consisting of 3 vincristine, actinomycin, and cyclophosphamide (VAC) and 2 platinum-based protocols. METHODS AND RESULTS: Median follow-up for 52 patients in the GCI study and 46 in GCII was 105 and 48 months, respectively. For GCI, 5- and 10-year actuarial survival was 63% (95% Confidence interval 50 to 75%) or 72% (57 to 83%) if 6 cases given low-dose VAC were excluded. For GCII, 5-year survival was significantly greater at 95% (83 to 99%), p = 0.01. Event-free survival was 46% at 5 years for GCI (33 to 59%) or 52% excluding the low-dose VAC cases (38 to 66%), while for GCII it was 87% (74 to 94%), p = 0.002. Five-year event-free survival of 21 children given cisplatin, etoposide, and bleomycin (BEP) in GCI was 57% (37 to 76%) compared with 87% (74 to 94%) for 46 given JEB in GCII, P = 0.02. Late effects in 30 evaluable survivors of GCI and 43 GCII included renal impairment in 6 in GCI and 0 in GCII and deafness in 11 and 4, respectively. Among 17 survivors of sacrococcygeal tumours treated in GCI, 4 have neuropathic bladder/bowel and another shortening of a leg. In GCII, 4 of 26 have neuropathic bladder/bowel with lower limb weakness in one. CONCLUSIONS: We found JEB to be more effective and less toxic than our previous regimens. Some survivors of sacrococcygeal tumours have neurological late effects.