Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Abstract Local schools increasingly play a mediating role between intended curricular directives and actual classroom practice. This paper highlights how macro factors such as decentralized governance and subject's institutional status affect school‐based decisions to diverge from official curricular policies. Specifically, it reports a three‐dimensional comparison from the Israeli education system, i.e. comparing educational levels (elementary and lower‐secondary), sectors (Jewish secular, Jewish religious, and Arab), and school subjects (with varying institutional status), to investigate patterns of diversity/uniformity in curricular structures. Between‐school variation in curriculum implementation tends to be greater under conditions of increased decentralization and school autonomy. Highly institutionalized subjects are more likely to be taught in conformity with official directives, thereby increasing between‐school uniformity. Important political and educational factors have a contextual influence on subject implementation, especially in certain sectors and levels. Ongoing trends toward educational decentralization not only encourage school autonomy, but also heighten curricular diversification. Local schools increasingly determine the educational knowledge students are offered, and effectively enable or constrain what teachers teach. Keywords: curriculumcurricular diversificationcurriculum implementationIsraelIsraeli‐Arab schools Acknowledgements This research was supported by grants from the Ministry of Education and from the Israeli Academy of Sciences. We thank the NCJW Research Institute for Innovation in Education, Hebrew University, for valuable administrative support during the study. Thanks are due to our many research assistants who helped in data collection and analysis, and to the school principals whose co‐operation made this research possible. Notes 1. See Beyer and Liston (1996 Beyer, L. E. and Liston, D. P. 1996. Curriculum in Conflict: Social Visions, Educational Agendas, and Progressive School Reform, New York: Teachers College Press. Google Scholar), Brint (1998 Brint, S. 1998. Schools and Societies, Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press. Google Scholar), Eggleston (1977 Eggleston, J. 1977. The Sociology of the School Curriculum, London: Routledge standard deviation/mean) standardizes variations across means and allows a comparison of between‐school variation for the different subject categories. To estimate between‐sector variations, we ran a set of ANOVAs for the subject categories. 16. The term 'hour' is used throughout this paper to denote one learning period (in Israel, 45 minutes). 17. Arab schools tend to allocate almost all of their resources to formal classroom hours, in order to ensure implementation of the required curriculum and, at times, to emphasize school subjects deemed most important. Very few resources are allocated for supplemental or non‐instructional purposes (e.g. special administrative positions, school counsellors, or the division of classes into ability groups or among electives). 18. For example, at the junior‐high school level (consisting of three grades), the range of weekly hours in the timetable of the 'poorest' and 'richest' schools was 92–138 hours in the Jewish secular sector, 75–165 hours in the Jewish religious sector and 96–129 hours in the Arab/Druze sector. The respective ranges at the elementary school level (also three grade levels) were as follows: 58–144 hours; 81–141 hours, and 86–135 hours. As learning time is an indicator of potential exposure to learning opportunities, both between‐sector and between‐school differences in learning time may be responsible for differential educational outcomes (Kilgore and Pendleton 1993 Kilgore, S. B. and Pendleton, W. W. 1993. The organizational context of learning: framework for understanding the acquisition of knowledge. Sociology of Education, 66(1): 63–87. Crossref , Google Scholar, Lavy 1998 Lavy, V. 1998. Disparities between Arabs and Jews in school resources and student achievement in Israel. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 47(1): 174–192. Google Scholar). 19. Originally, these subject categories appeared in many more schools. However, once we obtained more detailed estimates from those schools as to what subjects were expected to be taught, we were able to move many of the hours to other subject categories, so that 'Choice' and 'Flexible time' were reduced to a relatively minor category. 20. For details, see Benavot and Resh (2001 Benavot, A. and Resh, N. 2001. The social construction of local school curriculum: patterns of diversity and uniformity in Israeli junior high schools. Comparative Education Review, 45(4): 504–536. Crossref , Google Scholar). 21. A few exceptions to this general trend appear, however, suggesting interactions between school level and school subject. For example, the subject categories of 'arts and crafts' and 'skills and enrichment' appear to be more uniform on the elementary level than the lower‐secondary level: these subjects are implemented in most elementary schools (art in the Arab sector is an exception), are more strongly emphasized there, and are taught with a lower degree of variation in time allotment than in middle schools. In contrast, the subject of civics is found in many more middle schools than elementary schools, where related issues may be integrated in social education or some other interdisciplinary project. This suggests that certain subjects are regarded as more appropriate for younger children, while learning in middle schools is more 'serious' and so also more specialized, leaving less time for 'non‐essential' subjects (such as the arts). 22. Labelling this category 'religious education' may be misleading: only in the Jewish religious sector is a great deal of 'Jewish studies' geared to instill religious belief and the accompanying daily practice of religious commandments. In the Jewish secular sector, this category mostly reflects the study of Bible, mainly as a national cultural heritage. In the Arab sector, it combines cultural tradition and the study of holy books (Koran, New Testament, Druze heritage) for each of the Arab cultural/religious groups. 23. An exceptional case in point is physical education, which seems to be established as a highly institutionalized, but not highly valued subject. There is a strong consensus on its implementation as part of the weekly curriculum: it is implemented very uniformly and allotted a minimum amount of weekly time. 24. E.g. McEneaney and Meyer (2000 McEneaney, E. H. and Meyer, J. W. 2000. "The content of the curriculum: an institutionalist perspective". In Handbook of the Sociology of Education, Edited by: Hallinan, M. T. 189–211. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum. Google Scholar) and Pinar et al. (2002 Pinar, W. F., Reynolds, W. M., Slattery, P. and Taubman, P. M. 2002. Understanding Curriculum: An Introduction to the Study of Historical and Contemporary Curriculum Discourses, New York: Peter Lang. Google Scholar). 25. E.g. Bowles and Gintis (1976 Bowles, S. and Gintis, H. 1976. Schooling in Capitalist America: Educational Reform and the Contradictions of Economic Life, New York: Basic Books. Google Scholar), Oakes (1985 Oakes, J. 1985. Keeping Track: How Schools Structure Inequality, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Google Scholar), and Oakes et al. (1992 Oakes, J., Gamoran, A. and Page, R. N. 1992. "Curriculum differentiation: opportunities, outcomes, and meanings". In Handbook of Research on Curriculum, Edited by: Jackson, P. W. 570–608. New York: Macmillan. Google Scholar).
Resh et al. (Sun,) studied this question.