Does intensive health care advice through group sessions reduce cardiovascular risk factors compared to usual advice in adults with multiple cardiovascular risk factors?
Intensive health care advice via group sessions provided only limited additional benefit in reducing total cholesterol and Framingham risk compared to usual advice in primary care.
Abstract Objective : To evaluate the additional benefit of “intensive” health care advice through six group sessions, compared with the advice usually offered to subjects with multiple risk factors for cardiovascular disease. Design : Prospective, randomised controlled clinical study lasting 18 months. Setting : 681 subjects aged 30-59 years, with at least two cardiovascular risk factors in addition to moderately high lipid concentrations: total cholesterol >/=6.5 mmol/l on three occasions, triglycerides 4.0. Most (577) of the subjects were men. Main outcome measure : Percentage reduction in total cholesterol concentration (target 15%); quantification of the differences between the two types of health care advice (intensive v usual) for the Framingham cardiovascular risk and for individual risk factors. Results : In the group receiving intensive health care advice total cholesterol concentration decreased by 0.15 mmol/l more (95% confidence interval 0.04 to 0.26) than in the group receiving usual advice. The overall Framingham risk dropped by 0.068 more (0.014 to 0.095) in the group receiving intensive advice, and most of the risk factors showed a greater change in a favourable direction in this group than in the group receiving usual advice, but the differences were seldom significant. The results from questionnaires completed at the group sessions showed that the subjects improved their lifestyle and diet. Conclusion : Limited additional benefit was gained from being in the group receiving the intensive health care advice. It is difficult to make an important impact on cardiovascular risk in primary care by using only the practice staff. Better methods of communicating the messages need to be devised. Key messages Key messages This multicentre study examined the effects of “usual” or “intensive” health care advice on 681 subjects aged 30-59 years with a moderately high cholesterol concentration and two or more other cardiovascular risk factors The intensive advice programme was based mainly on group sessions led by doctors and nurses from health centres The study found that after 18 months of intervention limited additional benefit was derived from the intensive health care advice Messages and the means of delivering them to individuals in need should be customised for each person
Lindholm et al. (Sat,) studied this question.