Direct measurements of forces between phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine bilayers in aqueous electrolyte solutions

We report direct measurements of the full interbilayer force laws (force vs. distance) between bilayers of various phosphatidylcholines and phosphatidylethanolamine in aqueous solutions. Bilayers were first deposited on molecularly smooth (mica) surfaces and the interbilayer forces then measured at a resolution of 1 A. Three types of forces were identified: attractive van der Waals forces, repulsive electrostatic (double-layer) forces, and (at short range) repulsive steric hydration forces. Double-layer forces, which arise from ion binding, were insignificant in monovalent salt solutions, e.g., NaCl up to 1 M, but were already present in solutions containing millimolar levels of CaCl2 and MgCl2, giving rise to forces in excellent agreement with theory. Ca2+ binds more strongly than Mg2+, and both bind less to lecithin bilayers in the fluid state (T greater than Tc). The plane of charge coincides with the location of the negative phosphate groups, while the effective plane of origin of the van der Waals force is 4-5 A farther out. In water, the adhesion energies are in the range 0.10-0.15 erg/cm2 for lecithins and approximately 0.8 erg/cm2 for phosphatidylethanolamine. The adhesion energies vary on addition of salt due to changes in the repulsive double-layer and hydration forces rather than to a change in the attractive van der Waals force. The short-range repulsive forces which balance the van der Waals force at separations of 10-30 A are due to a combination of hydration and steric repulsions, the latter arising from thermal motions of head groups and thickness fluctuations of fluid bilayers (above Tc). It is also concluded that bilayer fusion is not simply related to the interbilayer force law.