Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
The position operator (defined within the Schr\"odinger representation in the standard way) becomes meaningless when periodic boundary conditions are adopted for the wave function, as usual in condensed matter physics. I show how to define the position expectation value by means of a simple many-body operator acting on the wave function of the extended system. The relationships of the present findings to the Berry-phase theory of polarization are discussed.
Raffaele Resta (Mon,) studied this question.