Research Activity and the Association with Mortality

INTRODUCTION: The aims of this study were to describe the key features of acute NHS Trusts with different levels of research activity and to investigate associations between research activity and clinical outcomes. METHODS: National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Comprehensive Clinical Research Network (CCRN) funding and number of patients recruited to NIHR Clinical Research Network (CRN) portfolio studies for each NHS Trusts were used as markers of research activity. Patient-level data for adult non-elective admissions were extracted from the English Hospital Episode Statistics (2005-10). Risk-adjusted mortality associations between Trust structures, research activity and, clinical outcomes were investigated. RESULTS: Low mortality Trusts received greater levels of funding and recruited more patients adjusted for size of Trust (n = 35, 2,349 £/bed 95% CI 1,855-2,843, 5.9 patients/bed 2.7-9.0) than Trusts with expected (n = 63, 1,110 £/bed, 864-1,357 p<0.0001, 2.6 patients/bed 1.7-3.5 p<0.0169) or, high (n = 42, 930 £/bed 683-1,177 p = 0.0001, 1.8 patients/bed 1.4-2.1 p<0.0005) mortality rates. The most research active Trusts were those with more doctors, nurses, critical care beds, operating theatres and, made greater use of radiology. Multifactorial analysis demonstrated better survival in the top funding and patient recruitment tertiles (lowest vs. highest (odds ratio & 95% CI: funding 1.050 1.033-1.068 p<0.0001, recruitment 1.069 1.052-1.086 p<0.0001), middle vs. highest (funding 1.040 1.024-1.055 p<0.0001, recruitment 1.085 1.070-1.100 p<0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Research active Trusts appear to have key differences in composition than less research active Trusts. Research active Trusts had lower risk-adjusted mortality for acute admissions, which persisted after adjustment for staffing and other structural factors.