Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Using market values for indexing gives more portfolio weight to the stocks with positive price errors and less portfolio weight to the stocks with negative price errors. Market-valuation-indifferent indexing—such as equal weighting or weighting by number of employees, number of customers, or sales—relies on averaging over hundreds of stocks to give equal weight to the two groups.
Jack L. Treynor (Thu,) studied this question.