Facial Reactions to Emotional Facial Expressions: Affect or Cognition?

This study investigated whether observers ’ facial reactions to the emotional facial expressions of others represent an affective or a cognitive response to these emotional expressions. Three hypotheses were contrasted: (1) facial reactions to emotional facial expressions are due to mimicry as part of an affective empathic reaction; (2) facial reactions to emotional facial expressions are a re ¯ ection of shared affect due to emotion induction; and (3) facial reactions to emotional facial expressions are determined by cognitive load depending on task dif ® culty. Two experiments were conducted varying type of task, presentation of stimuli, and task dif ® culty. The results show that depending on the nature of the rating task, facial reactions to facial expressions may be either affective or cognitive. Speci ® cally, evidence for facial mimicry was only found when individuals made judgements regarding the valence of an emotional facial expression. Other types of judgements regarding facial expressions did not seem to elicit mimicry but may lead to facial responses related to cognitive load.