Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Manuscripts reacting to the Belief Systems paper tackled by Judd and Milburn still cross my desk at the rate of better than a half-dozen a year. Only one in every three or four of these is published. However, whether published or unpublished, the verdict is certainly a mixed one, quite as these authors report; and my guess would be that if anything, disconfirmations are currently in the lead. In fact, I have seen so many disconfirmations in the past decade, and they form such repetitive patterns, that I consider myself something of an expert in the gambits necessary to produce disconfirmation. Invited to comment here, I thought it might be of some service to share these insights so that subsequent investigators can generate disconfirmations more surely and swiftly.
Philip E. Converse (Fri,) studied this question.