Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Three different ductile damage criteria, Ayada, normalized Cockcroft and Latham and a new shear stress based criterion taking into account hydrostatic tension, are utilized for predicting the onset of cracks in various deformation processes. It is found that the Ayada criterion predicts well the onset of cracks when they originate from hydrostatic tension. The shear based criterion predicts cracks triggered by shear and the normalized Cockcroft and Latham criterion indicates the overall area of onset of cracks caused by either hydrostatic or shear stresses. However the prediction is not as accurate as the Ayada criterion for cracks caused by hydrostatic tension.
Christiansen et al. (Sun,) studied this question.