Nitrogen transformations differentially affect nutrient‐limited primary production in lakes of varying trophic state

Abstract The concept of lakes “evolving” phosphorus (P) limitation has persisted in limnology despite limited direct evidence. Here, we developed a simple model to broadly characterize nitrogen (N) surpluses and deficits, relative to P, in lakes and compared the magnitude of this imbalance to estimates of N gains and losses through biological N transformations. The model suggested that approximately half of oligotrophic lakes in the U.S.A. had a stoichiometric N deficit, but 72–89% of eutrophic and hypereutrophic lakes, respectively, had a similar N deficit. Although reactive N appeared to accumulate in the most oligotrophic lakes, net denitrification perpetuated the N deficit in more productive lakes. Productive lakes exported reactive N via biological N transformations regardless of their N deficit. The lack of N accumulation through N fixation underscores the need for a modern eutrophication management approach focused on reducing total external nutrient loads, including both N and P.