The Moral Determinants of Health

The Moral Determinants of HealthThe source of what the philosopher Immanuel Kant called "the moral law within" may be mysterious, but its role in the social order is not.In any nation short of dictatorship some form of moral compact, implicit or explicit, should be the basis of a just society.Without a common sense of what is "right," groups fracture and the fragments wander.Science and knowledge can guide action; they do not cause action.No scientific doubt exists that, mostly, circumstances outside health care nurture or impair health.Except for a few clinical preventive services, most hospitals and physician offices are repair shops, trying to correct the damage of causes collectively denoted "social determinants of health."Marmot 1 has summarized these in 6 categories: conditions of birth and early childhood, education, work, the social circumstances of elders, a collection of elements of community resilience (such as transportation, housing, security, and a sense of community self-efficacy), and, cross-cutting all, what he calls "fairness," which generally amounts to a sufficient redistribution of wealth and income to ensure social and economic security and basic equity.Galea 2 has cataloged social determinants at a somewhat finer grain, calling out, for example, gun violence, loneliness, environmental toxins, and a dozen more causes.