Sustainable Pharmacy Education in the Time of COVID-19

Pharmacy schools and colleges worldwide are facing unprecedented challenges to ensuring sustainable education during the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. The experiences of pharmacy educators in the Asia-Pacific region in delivering emergency remote teaching, ensuring purposeful experiential placements, supporting displaced or isolated students, and communicating with faculty members, staff members, and students are discussed. The role of this pandemic in accelerating opportunities for new models of pharmacy education across the world is also discussed. Pharmacy schools and colleges worldwide are facing unprecedented challenges to ensuring sustainable education during the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. The experiences of pharmacy educators in the Asia-Pacific region in delivering emergency remote teaching, ensuring purposeful experiential placements, supporting displaced or isolated students, and communicating with faculty members, staff members, and students are discussed. The role of this pandemic in accelerating opportunities for new models of pharmacy education across the world is also discussed. Since the outbreak of the novel coronavirus in late 2019 (COVID-19), each day has brought breaking news about the disease, updated case numbers, and intense government announcements. These stories vary by global region but suggest a united concern for health care workers, the decisions they have to make, and the availability of vital resources to support their work (eg, personal protective equipment, medications, and ventilators). Personally and professionally, pharmacy educators worldwide have cycled through periods of stress then resilience, fear then relief, pessimism then hope. We have come to realize that there is only one “known”: we cannot precisely know what will happen. An editorial by Brazeau and Romanelli advises pharmacy educators to look for opportunity and purpose amid this adversity and, in some instances, tragedy that may surround us. 1. Brazeau G. Romanelli F. Navigating the uncharted waters in the time of COVID-19. Am J Pharm Educ. 2020; 84 (Article 8063) Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (12) Google Scholar Looking for opportunity and purpose, however, requires educators to approach work differently. In schools of pharmacy worldwide, we are used to long-term planning and staged implementation of major teaching initiatives. We ask each other, “what do we want our graduates to be able to do at the end of the program? ” and “How can we support the use of medicines and health technologies over the next 20 years? ” The best curricular teams are full of thinkers who begin with the end in mind and then work methodically to forecast, plan, and design for the future. We equally excel at identifying best practices and productively critiquing each other’s work until it is near what we believe is perfect. However, crises like the current pandemic challenge traditional approaches to long-term planning, staged implementation, best practices, and near-perfect work. To fulfil our responsibility to each other, our students, and the patients they will serve, we must be agile and connected. Because of COVID-19, many universities have transitioned to emergency remote delivery of courses (ie, mostly online and with no face-to-face interactions). At Monash University’s Faculty of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, we were fortunate in some aspects and challenged in others to achieve remote delivery. First, similar to other programs worldwide, we had recently undergone a curriculum transformation that included increased active learning, a focus on skill development, more experiential placements, and a required research project. Although these higher-yield learning approaches were crucial, they were more difficult than lectures to adjust quickly to remote delivery. Second, in the southern hemisphere, our first semester begins in early March. Therefore, our pharmacy students had only one day of face-to-face instruction on our campuses before the restrictions were implemented. Third, a relatively uncommon aspect of the Monash program is that we teach across two countries (Australia and Malaysia) and, hence, are governed by two professional accrediting bodies (ie, the Australian Pharmacy Council and the Malaysian Pharmacy Board). We follow a needs-based model where the unit coordinators (the equivalent of course directors in the United States) from each campus collaborate via Zoom (Zoom Video Communications, Inc. , San Jose, CA) to create instruction and assessments for both cohorts. 2. Anderson C. Bates I. Beck D. The WHO UNESCO FIP pharmacy education taskforce. Hum Resour Health. 2009; 45Google Scholar As some have suggested that COVID-19 has turned our world “upside down, ” we write this piece to share perspectives from “Down Under. ” Specifically, we outline ways that we have used sustainability principles to deliver emergency remote teaching, ensure purposeful experiential placements, support displaced or isolated students, and communicate with faculty and staff members and students in the Asia-Pacific region. We also discuss how this pandemic accelerates opportunities for new models of pharmacy education across the world. The literature is already brimming with best practices for online learning. 3. Volery T. Lord D. Critical success factors in online education. Int J Educ Manag. 2000; 14: 216-223Crossref Scopus (557) Google Scholar, 4. Means B. Bakia M. Murphy R. Learning Online: What Research Tells Us About Whether, When and How. Routledge, New York, NY2014Crossref Scopus (288) Google Scholar, 5. O’Neill K. Singh G. O’Donoghue Implementing eLearning programmes for higher education: a review of the literature. J Inf Technol Educ Res. 2004; 3: 313-323Google Scholar However, because of the short timeframe for implementation, we had to use pragmatic strategies. As a first step towards rapid online delivery, our unit teams in Australia and Malaysia focused on consistency across each year of the academic program (eg, P1, P2, P3, P4) and, when possible, across the entire curriculum. By creating consistency, instructors could more easily deputize and support each other. Also, students would experience similar formats, technologies, and expectations across their classes. As shown in Table 1, we considered each curricular element (eg, lectures) and agreed on a consistent approach for how this would be delivered online. Table 1Rapid Solutions to Delivering Emergency Remote Pharmacy Teaching in the Asia-Pacific Region After prioritizing consistency, we adapted a sustainability mindset, promoting a “reduce, reuse, recycle, and renew” approach. We reduced content, learning objectives, and synchronous learning requirements. We assumed that students could acquire knowledge through online platforms. When campus-based activities return, we plan to implement an intensive period when students will master skills they were unable to demonstrate fully online (eg, extemporaneous compounding). Instructors use asynchronous learning whenever possible to be considerate of students who may be working more pharmacy shifts, have caregiver responsibilities, are ill themselves, are sharing internet bandwidth with others, or had returned to their home country in a different time zone. Moreover, synchronous learning requires more instructor time and resources because of students who may miss activities and require remediation. However, we did create some synchronous touchpoints to build community between students and instructors. For example, instructors for each of our courses walked first-year students through the overall plans for the semester via a Zoom webinar. Following this overview, instructors responded live to questions posted online during the session. Some of our previously planned workshops were reduced in content, but we delivered them synchronously to smaller groups of students. For example, we used the “breakout room” feature of Zoom and randomly sorted students into rooms of two to three to role-play patient counselling. We reused previous lecture recordings, assessments, and learning materials. When still relevant, instructors reformatted recorded lectures from the previous year. For some of our 2019 lecture recordings, instructors cut these into segments of approximately nine minutes. They then added interactive response questions and activities in between the lecture segments. This enabled students to test and retest between the key concepts. We also reused student questions from previous clarification sessions to develop online posts with frequently asked questions. Instructors recycled previously created assessments and material for student remediation and self-study. For example, many of our face-to-face workshops were reduced to the necessary components for students to complete online. The activities and materials that were removed from the workshops were used for student remediation and posted as optional activities (eg, practice quizzes) for students who desired more practice with the material. Finally, our faculty members renewed their connection to crucial academic and practice partners worldwide. We reached out to our medical faculty members to align our expectations of what students could achieve online and what they needed to learn through experience. This dialogue was constructive in keeping expectations harmonized across the health professions. We prioritized interprofessional learning activities, which, despite being more logistically difficult to implement online, emphasized the very teamwork critical during a pandemic response. 6. Kent F, George J, Lindley J, Brock T. Virtual workshops to preserve interprofessional collaboration while physical distancing published online ahead of print April 2020. Med Educ. Google Scholar We also regularly contacted our professional bodies and practitioner partners to stay current with their needs and pressure points. Instructors renewed their commitment to building a community among our learners. For example, we hosted a virtual online welcome ceremony for our international students to help connect learners (especially those new to our university) to other students and resources. During the welcome ceremony, we discussed everything from the new delivery of learning to the cultural role of Vegemite (a food spread) and Tim Tams (a chocolate cookie) in Australia. We even developed a virtual career fair to ensure our graduating pharmacy students could connect with postgraduate internship employers (the next required step for fourth-year pharmacy students in Australia). The public needs access to medicines and reliable health systems, and these needs are amplified in times of crisis. To address these needs, pharmacists in community and hospital settings are critical. In the professional oath, pharmacists are called to place the needs of others above their own interests. 7. Oath of a Pharmacist. International Pharmaceutical Federation. https: //www. fip. org/files/fip/FIPPharmacistₒathA4withₛignature. pdf. Adopted August 31, 2014. Accessed April 30, 2020. Google Scholar Our students are pharmacists in training who now more than ever are a critical part of health care delivery. In response to the pressures of COVID-19, we have observed health profession schools take one of three approaches to clinical education: containment, learning, or workforce support. With a containment approach, programs remove all students from practice sites to reduce transmission risk and focus on essential services. In a learning approach, programs keep students at practice sites to participate in their usual activities or observe pandemic response activities. With a workforce support approach, programs “skill up” students to support the pandemic response activities. Examples of the workforce support approach include repurposing medication supplies from different sources, providing information to patients and caregivers, and helping to ensure medication access. As a first step at Monash, we followed the World Health Organization (WHO), governmental, and department of health guidance. Next, we connected with medical faculty members to ascertain their approach regarding health professional students in experiential sites during the pandemic. We then connected with the professional and regulatory bodies that support pharmacy practice in Australia and Malaysia. We agreed that site-based capacities were critical considerations. Finally, we contributed to the development of guiding principles for pharmacy student clinical education during a global health emergency via the Council of Pharmacy Schools (CPS): Australia and New Zealand. 8. Council of Pharmacy Schools: Australia and New Zealand. Guiding principles for pharmacy student clinical education during a global health emergency. https: //www. pharmacycouncil. org. au/news-publications/news/200424-cps-guiding-principles-for-clinical-education. pdf. Published April 24, 2020. Accessed April 30, 2020. Google Scholar Together, the CPS programs advocated for a workforce support approach, ie, the continuation of placements in health settings that welcomed and could safely support a workforce support approach. Through phone and email communications with our sites, we reinforced site-specific adjustments such as restricting students to specific areas or specialties. In Malaysia, however, the government-issued movement control order meant that student experiential placements for all health professional programs had to be delayed. We had regular communications (email and via Zoom) with our final-year students who were on experiential placements during this period. These were not always easy conversations, including topics like personal health risk, cultural norms (eg, mask wearing), and professional responsibility. We endorsed three options for students: stay on placement to support the health system in somewhat altered roles; take a break from the placement temporarily with an alternate schedule for completing the placement forthcoming; or take an intermission from the degree program for this year. To support student wellbeing, we reinforced the availability of physical and mental health support services accessible free of charge and without stigma. As we were receiving increasing requests from health care settings for pharmacy students willing to take on additional support roles, we started a registry of students who were interested in volunteering for a “surge workforce. ” Then, we connected with our local professional bodies and sites to support the registry. We also aligned our overall efforts with our medicine, nursing, and allied health programs, taking the approach that where other health professions students are contributing, pharmacy students should be contributing, too. 9. Dooley M. Thank you on behalf of the JPPR. J Pharm Prac Res. 2020; 50: 117-121Crossref Scopus (4) Google Scholar Before the number of COVID-19 cases increased exponentially in Australia, the virus did not affect the day-to-day lives of most of our instructors and domestic students. It did, however, result in travel bans that kept many of our international students from being able to come to Australia to study. As a team, we led with empathy for what these students may have initially experienced. We encouraged all domestic students to think about what it might be like to worry about a loved one. Only a few months later, this became a shared reality. One of our first actions in establishing an online teaching and learning system for our international students was to recruit Mandarin-speaking facilitators for each of the first-year units. Although our instruction is usually delivered only in English, we thought international students would appreciate communicating the complexities of their situation and being introduced to the active-learning model in their native language. In addition to empathy, we promoted dignity. It was necessary that these students be able to integrate with their Australian cohorts and feel like they belonged. Early in the pandemic, we emphasized to students that COVID-19 was not a “Chinese” virus and should not be described as such because such misnomers often reflect and perpetuate prejudices. Instead of referring to the students now studying from China as “COVID-impacted students, ” we designated the displaced students as “Group 9” to mimic our usual student grouping structure (ie, we allocate students into one of eight workshop groups). We were delighted to learn that nine represents longevity in Chinese culture. We supported these students in this distinct way until they joined the wider cohort back in Australia, by which time, most of the program for all students had converted to online delivery. Although online delivery of the pharmacy curriculum has allowed us to continue training future pharmacists during this crisis, there is no doubt that some access to on-campus instruction better encourages the connections students develop with their school, their peers, and what they are learning. Even in the earliest stages of this remote model of education delivery, we were hearing students grieve over the loss of casual interactions with their peers, and participating in cocurricular activities and social events. Although some students find distance education more convenient, many say it is difficult to motivate themselves to learn deeply when they lack these personal connections. Academics are mourning this as well. The memories of our collegial interactions at libraries, coffee shops, and conferences leave holes in the experience for faculty members as well. Because of we are by the efforts such as virtual coffee and even Our students had many questions about the in the the use of new technologies, they should back to their home countries to and they should continue in the program at To address these our initially to all student This is a practice to reduce the risk of among Because our local approach is very however, our pharmacy with this communications were we out email and recorded between instructors and students. Our student which from each cohort and key student to We also Zoom sessions for all first-year students and Zoom sessions for all students to mimic our usual practice of for To students and instructors with new technologies, we training and resources on our virtual technologies (ie, Zoom) for use in included for and recorded Instructors each other in of new teaching We created a for COVID-19 adjustments on the of on our learning system (ie, Faculty and staff members regular email from and faculty The were as can fully all in the of a crisis. Moreover, it is in these for to experience Faculty and staff members are more to to communications that Our emphasized the to deliver on our of education and while ensuring workforce and In the was to focus on the and learning. We social to how our education was being delivered and to our approach. Our that would require of our activities to ensure that we our without student and staff This meant that we some and because were with to the way education was delivered and research was we to faculty and staff members to fulfil their staff with their to address their and a working When the COVID-19 education and health care will be and students will be of will be This is not how we had already our health care In previously to take were in a of In Australia, restrictions to and were removed the Australian government new that affect health an of for free for health care workers, for mental health and the of our academic will be will be more with working from This will education to Instructors will be more with a of platforms. will the of new which has often the case an or This the efforts of and students in one across two countries in the Asia-Pacific region to the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic. Some of what we at Monash have during this pandemic may be different from the by universities in other of the world. However, despite the distance between we of what we have described will with other pharmacy Although we have some of our academic to with the of the pandemic, our as long-term will be critical as we the To a sustainable future in health pharmacy educators must reuse, recycle, and most this experience has amplified the for schools and colleges of pharmacy worldwide to work It may also pharmacy education to global the way other health professions are for and challenges in the development of a global medical published online ahead of print April 2020. Scholar of we have a responsibility to pharmacy students to be and for now and for the next global pandemic. The all pharmacy unit teaching professional and research staff in Australia and Malaysia who have contributed to this We also our students for with us in these