Comparative Perceptual Assessment of Visual Signals Using Free Energy Features

In this paper, we put forward the concept of comparative perceptual quality assessment (C-PQA), which refers to the judgment of relative qualities of two visual signals of the same content, but subject to different types and levels of distortions. While it is straightforward for human observers to fulfill the CPQA task in daily lives, it remains a difficult challenge for the current research of perceptual quality assessment (PQA). Among the existing PQA algorithms, the full-reference (FR) and reducedreference (RR) methods both need prior knowledge of the original images while the no-reference (NR) algorithms usually work with a single input image. C-PQA is inherently different from those existing methods in that it takes an image pair as input and predicts their relative quality without using any knowledge about the original image. In this paper, we propose a brain theory inspired approach to C-PQA that emulates the process of comparing the relative quality of two visual stimuli as performed by the human visual system (HVS) within the framework of free energy minimization. The brain's internal generative models initialized on the inputs are then used to explain both images. During the internal generative modeling, a group of features are extracted and then integrated to determine the relative quality of two images. We designed a dedicated image database to test the proposed C-PQA algorithm. Experimental results show that the proposed method achieves up to 98% prediction accuracy in line with the subjective ratings, outperforming many state of the art PQA algorithms.