The role of intervention mechanisms on a self-organized system: dynamics of a sandpile with site reinforcement

Abstract We revisit the sandpile model and examine the effect of introducing site-dependent thresholds that increase over time based on the generated avalanche size. This is inspired by the simplest means of introducing stability into a self-organized system: the locations of collapse are repaired and reinforced. Statistically, for the case of finite driving times, we observe that the site-dependent reinforcements decrease the occurrence of very large avalanches, leading to an effective global stabilization. Interestingly, however, long simulation runs indicate that the system will persist in a state of self-organized criticality (SOC), recovering the power-law distributions with a different exponent as the original sandpile. These results suggest that tipping the heavy-tailed power-laws into more equitable and normal statistics may require unrealistic scales of intervention for real-world systems, and that, in the long run, SOC mechanisms still emerge. This may help explain the robustness of power-law statistics for many complex systems.